
Praise Economy
Jill McDonough | Poetry
A lady tells me she loves my black down skirt and I say
I love your coat! And I do! Cheyney says this kind
of backatcha, babe! response is too easy, undoes
the kindness. Some German told him you should just
take it, say thanks, or you’re screwing it up. I tell him No,
Italians say Grazie VUOI, or No, thank YOU, and
Wait, so you’re trusting the GERMANS on joy? A praise
economy: sort of like what Gaby calls it, maybe what
I call making strangers happy with my face, stranger
faces grinning back at me, their winks and chin jerks, our
sweethearts and hons. And the men by the park who call
me mami, say they want to go home with me. I’m going
to the park! I offer, chipper; what am I thinking? It doesn’t
matter, they never come along. These dumb things we
can say to each other are the whole point of leaving the house.
Except to buy books for Dave and Sarah, whose key we forgot
to give back in New Orleans, and pick up scallops for early
supper in front of a new tv. Oh, and work, I guess, seeing
five thousand year old Sumerian tablets, giving Kim
the hot librarian glass Mardi Gras beads, telling Sophie
the frustrated sophomore to give the sonnet another shot, but
she’s super either way. Even just a list of their names enriches
me, I’m thinking, reaching for each man’s death diminishes me,
and almost getting there. We watch Natasha Lyonne on the new
tv telling Nick Nolte she wants to go back, undo her friend’s
death, or understand it, and we are sobbing, laughing at how pat
it is, how these tears undo nothing yet. They undo nothing, but
keeping it in can’t do us any good. Telling the truth, telling
the people we love that we love them, like telling all the ladies
I love their cute coats, must be doing something right. Right?
Three-time Pushcart prize winner Jill McDonough is the recipient of Lannan, NEA, Cullman Center, and Stegner fellowships. Her most recent book is American Treasure (Alice James, 2022). She directs the MFA program at UMass-Boston and started a program offering College Reading and Writing in two Boston jails. Her website: jillmcdonough.com.